Most of the models developed to model malaria parasite infections in mosquitoes look at the infection states: uninfected; infected; or infected and infectious. A few models have been developed that track also track parity. A different class of models tracks the behavioral / physiological state of mosquitoes, so we call them behavioral state models. A model with both infection states and behavioral states was first published by Le Menach, et al. (2005)1.

The Model

This is a patch-based model with pp patches, and we assume that all the parameters, variables, and terms are of length pp except for Ωb\Omega_b and Ωq\Omega_q, which are p×pp \times p matrices.

Variables

  • UbU_b - uninfected, blood feeding mosquitoes

  • UqU_q - uninfected, egg laying mosquitoes

  • YbY_b - infected but not infective, blood feeding mosquitoes

  • YqY_q - infected but not infective, egg laying mosquitoes

  • ZbZ_b - infective, blood feeding mosquitoes

  • ZqZ_q - infective, egg laying mosquitoes

Terms

Two terms are passed from another component of the model.

  • Λ\Lambda - the emergence rate of adult mosquitoes from aquatic habitats in each patch

  • κ\kappa - the net infectiousness of humans, the probability a mosquito becomes infected after blood feeding on a human

Parameters

Bionomics - Each one of the following parameters can take on a unique value in each patch.

  • ff - the blood feeding rate

  • qq - the human blood feeding fraction

  • ν\nu - the egg laying rate

  • gg - the mosquito death rate, per mosquito

  • φ\varphi - the rate that infected mosquitoes become infective, the inverse of the EIP

  • σb\sigma_b - the patch emigration rate for blood-feeding mosquitoes

  • σq\sigma_q - the patch emigration rate for egg-laying mosquitoes

  • μ\mu - the emigration loss rate: excess mortality associated with migration

Dipsersal Matrices - Each one of the following parameters can take on a unique value in each patch.

  • ${\cal K}_b$ - the dispersal matrix for blood-feeding mosquitoes, which has the form: $${\cal K} = \left[ \begin{array}{ccccl} 0 & k_{1,2} & k_{1,3} & \ldots & k_{1,p} \\ k_{2,1} & 0 & k_{2,3} & \ldots & k_{2,p} \\ k_{3,1} & k_{3,2} & 0 & \ldots & k_{3,p} \\ \vdots& \vdots &\vdots & \ddots & k_{p-1, p} \\ k_{p,1} & k_{p,2} & k_{p,3} & \ldots & 0 \\ \end{array} \right].$$ The diagonal elements are all 00, and other elements, $k_{i,j} \in {\cal K}$, are the fraction of blood feeding mosquitoes leaving patch jj that end up in patch ii; the notation should be read as iji \leftarrow j, or to ii from jj. Notably, the form of $\cal K$ is constrained such that iki,j=1.\sum_i k_{i,j} = 1.

  • ${\cal K}_q$ - the dispersal matrix for egg-laying mosquitoes, which has the same form as ${\cal K}_b$

The Demographic Matrices

  • Ωb\Omega_b - the demographic matrix for blood feeding mosquitoes; letting II denote the identity matrix, $$\Omega_b = \mbox{diag}\left(g\right) - \mbox{diag}\left(\sigma_b\right) \left(\mbox{diag}\left(1-\mu\right) - \cal K_b \right)$$

  • Ωq\Omega_q - the demographic matrix for egg laying mosquitoes; which has the same form as Ωb\Omega_b.

Dynamics

The following equations track adult mosquito behavioral and infection dynamics. A key assumption is that a fraction qκq\kappa of blood feeding, uninfected mosquitoes become infected, thus transition from UbU_b to Yg.Y_g.

dUbdt=Λ+νUgfUbΩbUbdUgdt=f(1qκ)UbνUgΩgUgdYbdt=νYg+ϕYg(f+φ)YgΩbYbdYgdt=fqκUb+fYb(ν+φ)YgΩgYgdZbdt=φYb+νZgfZΩbZbdZgdt=φYg+fZνZΩqZq \begin{array}{rl} \dfrac{dU_b}{dt} &= \Lambda + \nu U_g - f U_b - \Omega_b \cdot U_b \\ \dfrac{dU_g}{dt} &= f (1- q \kappa) U_b - \nu U_g - \Omega_g \cdot U_g \\ \dfrac{dY_b}{dt} &= \nu Y_g + \phi Y_g - (f+\varphi) Y_g - \Omega_b \cdot Y_b \\ \dfrac{dY_g}{dt} &= f q \kappa U_b + f Y_b - (\nu + \varphi) Y_g - \Omega_g \cdot Y_g \\ \dfrac{dZ_b}{dt} &= \varphi Y_b + \nu Z_g - f Z - \Omega_b \cdot Z_b \\ \dfrac{dZ_g}{dt} &= \varphi Y_g + f Z - \nu Z - \Omega_q \cdot Z_q \end{array}

Implementation

The xds_setup() utilities allow the user to pass a single version of the dispersal matrix $\cal K.$ During xds_setup(), Omega_b and Omega_q are identical.

HPop = rep(1000, 3)
residence = c(1:3) 
model <- xds_setup(MYZname="RMG", Lname="trivial", Xname = "trivial",  residence=residence, HPop =HPop, nPatches=3)
model <- xds_solve(model, dt=5)
par(mfrow = c(2,1))
xds_plot_M(model)
xds_plot_YZ(model, add_axes = F)
xds_plot_YZ_fracs(model)
xds_plot_YZ_fracs(model)

  1. Menach AL, et al. The unexpected importance of mosquito oviposition behaviour for malaria: non-productive larval habitats can be sources for malaria transmission. Malar J 4, 23 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1186/1475-2875-4-23↩︎